Get in touch
Pandemics and panics - what are we doing about it?
3 March 2020
Not much... for now.
We are already positioned cautiously because markets are (probably) quite expensive. We have noted how many other low conviction long equity investors are waiting beside the fire exit. So should we get off the equity bandwagon ahead of (or during) the rush? Frankly, we are not sure and we don’t think it’s time to fight the Fed.
Do we even know if the latest sell-off is the start of something bigger?
If the numbers coming out of China are to be believed, then the spread of the virus has slowed dramatically within China’s borders. However, it is quite possible (and we have heard it to be the case) that Hubei province has simply not reported for the last few days. The recent flat-lining of the Chinese data could support this thesis, just as it could indicate that the drastic actions of the Chinese authorities have been successful. What we do know is that confirmed cases outside of China have surged but overall remain comparatively low. That means the data is quite lumpy with the Diamond Princess cruise ship, a Church in Korea and a group of small towns in northern Italy having an outsized impact on the data.
Jonathan Ramsay — February 26, 2020
Jonathan Ramsay — February 26, 2020
Listen to the InvestSense Podcast with Andrew Hunt
We have heard from various sources that sustained growth rates in confirmed cases of the virus above 20% are cause for serious concern while rates in the low teens would point to something more manageable. The last few days we saw those levels breached. While it was probably inevitable that we would see an initial ramp-up in cases as the focus moved from Chinese containment to global coping, the media in the Western world has reached fever pitch levels in the last few days. What we don’t know is whether this is another set-back that will ultimately be seen as a buying opportunity or the straw that broke the back of the global economy.
In fact, we can’t even be sure that it is just the Coronavirus that has caused the recent falls in markets (bear in mind that while media headlines make for compelling narratives we still don’t know with absolute certainty what caused the 1987 crash thirty-three years and many books later). One compelling reason, or contributing factor, for recent market turmoil, is the polling of the Democratic Nomination in the US where Bernie Sanders’ standing jumped markedly in recent days vs the more market-friendly Joe Biden. Compared to the unknowns of the Coronavirus, the economic impact of a Sanders Presidency is relatively easy for markets to discount (given the prevailing assumptions of most market participants).
In fact, we can’t even be sure that it is just the Coronavirus that has caused the recent falls in markets (bear in mind that while media headlines make for compelling narratives we still don’t know with absolute certainty what caused the 1987 crash thirty-three years and many books later). One compelling reason, or contributing factor, for recent market turmoil, is the polling of the Democratic Nomination in the US where Bernie Sanders’ standing jumped markedly in recent days vs the more market-friendly Joe Biden. Compared to the unknowns of the Coronavirus, the economic impact of a Sanders Presidency is relatively easy for markets to discount (given the prevailing assumptions of most market participants).
It is, of course, early days in this race but in this respect Bernie has form. It is highly plausible that the last time the US felt the ’Burn’ was not a particularly market-friendly environment, and that was before the world had really contemplated the possibilities of populist policies. This reminds us that markets are volatile precisely because they quickly discount future scenarios, that may or may not happen. Sell the rumour buy the fact?
The market has also spent much of the last 30 years making life difficult for asset allocators and forecasters. The market has fallen by 5% or more 27 times in that period. 12 of those happened during a bear market but these occurrences were concentrated within 5 years (2000-3 and 2007-8). The rest of the time they proved to be feints that left many hapless investors whipsawed and wrong-sided on both the fall and the subsequent rebound. Of course, the time will come (possibly quite soon) when it becomes apparent that we are deep into something bigger but in our view right now there is simply not enough tangible information to convince us to become more defensive than we already are. This is a subjective view which we discussed this evening with Andrew Hunt, who we consider to be more ‘plugged-in’ than ourselves. He too remains on the fence but, absent any further developments, awaits data from the US Federal Reserve on Friday which should reveal the extent to which the US central bank is willing to support markets in the way that the People’s Bank of China evidently has been recently.
Postscript
The markets continued their wild swings overnight. Europe plummeted and then mostly recovered while the US then opened up and retraced its steps later on. At times like these, we find these multi-day/intra-day charts useful in interpreting the swings in sentiment and how they shift across the globe. In this one, it is interesting to note that Asia has started to be strangely resilient when compared to the early part of the month. Maybe the focus is shifting to how the Coronavirus will affect the Northern Hemisphere and the West. Or maybe it has indeed more to do with what is happening in the US, or at least the sentiment of US investors?
Latest News
Navigating Inheritances. Nicholes Family Law Partners Nadine Udorovic and Bec Dahl chat to Danny Archer and Damian McMahon. Together, they delve into the complexities of inheritances, offering valuable insights from both legal and financial perspectives on how to navigate this important topic.
Watch the video above from Thayne. As 2024 comes to a close I thought I'd take the opportunity and send a thank you note to you all as gratitude for your continued support and loyalty. Throughout 2024 we have experienced; 1. Exceptional investment returns from all asset classes and sectors: ASX 200 up 23% S&P 500 up 30% AUST. Bonds up ~4.5% INTERNATIONAL Bonds up ~6% Aust Retail Property Trust up 39% 2. This hopefully reminds you all that it's best to remain invested even when economic conditions are uncertain. 3. We are actively monitoring and keeping an eye on US economic data particularly to understand which direction inflation may head, how this will impact interest rates and currency valuations, will there be a resurgence of small companies, emerging markets and bond and property prices. 4. With our research team we are well positioned to keep on top of the ever changing landscape, making investment decisions to maximise returns and minimise risk with regular investment committee meetings and analysis of data. 5. For many of our actively managed investment portfolios we ranked in the top 5 if not top 10 of throughout the course of the year which is a testament to the structure of Mulcahy & Co offices, people, systems and processes that we continue to build on to provide a quality service and outcomes to you all. 6. Please remember here at Mulcahy & Co the Financial Planning team is a part of a bigger network incorporating Accounting, Lending and Legal to deliver Financial Security 360 to make sure all of your financial needs are met and complement each other to achieve your goals and objectives. Once again I'd like to thank you for your support and wish you and your families a Merry Christmas and happy new year. The Mulcahy & Co Financial Planning Team
We meet Accounting Partner Eamon and Mark from Compass Business Accountants who has joined the Mulcahy & Co Group operating from our Toowoomba, Queensland office. Host Gavin Nash talks to the pair who are operating from this thriving inland city and what services they offer their clients.
Quicklinks
Tools
Office Locations
Mulcahy & Co acknowledges all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Traditional Custodians of Country and recognises their continuing connection to land, sea, culture and community. We pay our respects to Elders past and present.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation - A MEMBER OF LAW AUSTRALIA
Australian Financial Services Licence No. 340094
Mulcahy & Co Financial Services Pty Ltd is a credit representative (397076) of BLSSA Pty Ltd ACN 117 651 760 (Australian Credit Licence 391237)