Is there a hidden risk in your super fund?

2 December 2022

How did so many super funds manage to shoulder such a volatile market period?

James Thompson’s opinion piece “Is there a hidden risk in your superfund?” (Australian Financial Review 2022) calls to light some dark behaviour happening under investors noses within the superannuation industry. Thompson begins by highlighting the “impressive resilience” of the performance of many Australian super funds, given the strong market downturn that investors have experienced this year. He compares the average return (negative 5.7%) in the default ‘MySuper’ balanced options from the 12 months ending September 2022, against that of a “tried-and-true 60/40 portfolio” (approximately negative 12%).

So how did so many super funds manage to shoulder such a volatile market period?


Almost 50% of Aussie super funds hold significant investments in “unlisted assets” (i.e. direct property & infrastructure, credit and private equity). Thompson strongly believes that most Australians don’t know what their super fund actually holds, let alone the risks that can be associated with these unlisted assets.


Unlike direct shares or managed funds, the day-to-day price of unlisted assets are not reported. As such, these assets are often utilised by superannuation funds to smooth a trend line and bolster results when required. Thomson elaborates on the risk associated with this lack of transparency – he believes that many super funds are underquoting the associated risk of their unlisted assets, in order to chase headline returns, while continuing to associate their investment options with terms like balanced or conservative. To further his point, he refers to the illiquid nature of these holdings, and the inability to move them off the books quickly if cash was required (i.e. for member withdrawals). In times of need, such assets can often be sold off for heavily discounted prices.


Thompson concludes that many Australians could be over-exposed to illiquidity risk, which is particularly important for those relying on superannuation to pay for their retirement. He believes that super funds must be held more accountable with their asset allocation and calls for a more uniform measure of risk measurement.


Here at Mulcahy & Co, our suite of portfolios provides a level of transparency that we believe is top tier. Not only do we hold little to no unlisted assets, but our clients have the ability to view the exact (to the cent) allocation of their funds. We wholeheartedly concur that liquidity and appropriate risk exposure are incredibly important factors to consider when deciding where your money is invested.


Click here to read the full article (a subscription to the Australian Financial Review is required)


If you have any queries or concerns about your super fund or other investments, please get in contact with your financial adviser at Mulcahy & Co.


Jesse Jury

Financial Planning - Mulcahy & Co Geelong

Latest News

Sperannuation tax changes for large balances
15 October 2025
The government has announced it will make some practical changes to its proposed tax changes for people with large super balances (over $3 million) that will now take effect from 1 July 2026.
10 October 2025
Big changes are on the way for aged care, with new rules starting from 1 November 2025. While these changes aim to create a more sustainable and fairer system, they do bring added complexity — especially when it comes to understanding the fees and making the right financial decisions. Here are the five key things you need to know: 1. Aged care will cost more - but is still subsidised If you or a loved one is moving into residential aged care from 1 November 2025, the amount you’ll need to contribute will be higher. That said, the Government will continue to fund a large share of care costs - around 73% on average. But it will be important to consider your cashflow. 2. Expect new terminology and fee calculations The language is changing. Instead of the current “means-tested care fee,” you’ll now see new names like Hotelling Contribution and Non-Clinical Care Contribution. How much you are asked to pay will still be based on your income and assets, but new formulae may result in higher contributions than under the current rules. 3. Lifetime caps remain – but at a higher level A lifetime cap will continue to apply to limit how much you can be asked to pay as a non-clinical care contribution over your total stay in residential care. This cap is increasing to $130,000, but with a new safeguard, that no matter how much you pay, you will only need to pay this fee for a maximum of four years. This helps ensure fairness between residents with different levels of wealth. 4. Retention amounts are being reintroduced If you choose to pay a lump sum for your room (known as a refundable accommodation deposit - RAD), aged care providers will deduct a “retention amount” of up to 2% per year (capped at 10% over five years). While this increases the cost slightly, it may still be better value than paying the daily accommodation payment. 5. Good advice can prevent costly mistakes Navigating these new rules can be confusing - especially when you need to make major decisions about the family home, assets or pension entitlements. The cost of getting good advice is often small compared to the cost of getting it wrong. That’s why seeking qualified aged care financial advice is more important than ever.  If you're starting to think about aged care for yourself or a family member, now is the time to start planning and seek advice. As specialists in aged care advice, we can help you to make informed decisions with confidence and peace of mind. Please contact Lynde via the link below to chat more about these changes.
Victoria's Commercial and Industrial Property Tax Reform
19 June 2025
Victoria's 'Commercial and Industrial Property Tax Reform' and how this will affect Stamp Duty for these properties is discussed with Principal Solicitor Brad Matthews and host Gavin Nash. Changes are coming on July 1st 2024 in this area and Brad gives us great insight into how and what is changing - and when!
Vacant Residential Property Tax
19 June 2025
Victoria's 'Vacant Residential Property Tax' is discussed with Principal Solicitor Brad Matthews and host Gavin Nash. Changes are coming on July 1st 2024 in this area and Brad gives us great insight into how and what is changing - and when!
Show More